Schedule A Litigation in 2026: Is the Brand Owner's Favourite Anti-Counterfeiting Tool Still Worth It?

By CrossBorder IP · Published November 5, 2026

Schedule A Litigation in 2026: Is the Brand Owner's Favourite Anti-Counterfeiting Tool Still Worth It?

If you run an e-commerce brand, you have probably heard of Schedule A litigation, even if you have never filed one. It is the model that lets a brand owner sue dozens or even hundreds of anonymous online sellers in a single US federal case, freeze their marketplace accounts before they can move the money, and often finish with default judgments. For more than a decade, it has been one of the most effective ways to hit counterfeit networks that hide behind marketplace storefronts.

In 2026, two things are true at once. Brands are filing more Schedule A cases than ever. And the courts that made the model possible are scrutinising it more closely than ever. This guide explains how the model works, what has changed, and how to decide whether — and how — to use it now.

How Schedule A litigation works

The name comes from the practice of listing the defendants — usually online storefronts identified only by seller names and URLs — in a schedule attached to the complaint and filed under seal, rather than in the case caption. The typical sequence looks like this:

  1. Investigation: the brand identifies counterfeit listings and makes test purchases.
  2. Sealed filing: the complaint names the sellers in a sealed Schedule A to avoid tipping them off.
  3. Ex parte TRO: the court grants a temporary restraining order, often freezing marketplace accounts and payment balances, before defendants receive notice.
  4. Electronic service: because many sellers are overseas with unreliable addresses, courts may authorise service by email or online publication.
  5. Default or settlement: many defendants never appear; the rest settle, frequently from frozen funds.

The Northern District of Illinois became the dominant venue, to the point that Chicago’s federal court became one of the busiest IP dockets in the country.

Filings are still climbing

Demand has not cooled. A September 2026 analysis by The Fashion Law of five major fashion and luxury brands found 74 Schedule A filings in the first eight months of 2026 alone — more than double the 35 those brands filed in all of 2025. One streetwear brand went from zero Schedule A cases through 2025 to 16 by the end of August 2026. Plaintiffs now include automakers, sports franchises, gaming companies, and entertainment studios, as well as fashion houses.

The headline for 2026: Schedule A is still a powerful tool, but the courts are now enforcing the ordinary rules — jurisdiction, joinder, service — that some plaintiffs had treated as formalities. Cases built on thin evidence are failing.

Where the courts are pushing back

Personal jurisdiction

The Seventh Circuit has made clear that operating a website accessible in Illinois — even one capable of taking orders for shipment there — does not by itself establish personal jurisdiction over a seller. Completed sales into Illinois can supply the necessary contact. The court has also vacated a default judgment against online sellers where the plaintiff failed to establish jurisdiction. The practical lesson: test buys shipped into the forum are no longer optional evidence.

Joinder

Schedule A depends on suing many sellers together. For years, plaintiffs relied on a counterfeiting swarm theory: unrelated sellers causing simultaneous harm could be joined even without proof they coordinated. Judges in Chicago have grown sceptical. In May 2026, a judge severed six defendants from a Chrome Hearts action against 92 online sellers, finding the brand had not shown they were sufficiently connected to be sued together.

Forum and judge shopping

Courts are policing attempts to steer cases to favourable judges. In early 2026, a Northern District of Illinois judge dismissed a Schedule A case with prejudice after the plaintiff dropped most defendants once the case was assigned to him, having named the same defendants in earlier cases before other judges — conduct the court called an egregious form of forum shopping. Another judge previously stayed more than 50 Schedule A cases to reassess the model, noting plaintiffs were free to file elsewhere.

Service on overseas defendants

Courts are also examining whether plaintiffs made reasonable efforts to find physical addresses for defendants — many of them in China — before seeking permission for electronic service. Where an address is reasonably discoverable, international service rules may apply.

Other venues

As Chicago tightened, some filings moved. The District of New Jersey saw enough of an uptick that its chief judge issued a standing order addressing Schedule A cases in September 2025. Expect each new venue to develop its own expectations rather than serving as an easy alternative.

Is Schedule A still worth it?

For many brands, yes — with a more disciplined approach. Schedule A remains one of the few tools that can reach anonymous, offshore sellers quickly and recover money from them. But the cost of a weak case has gone up: severed defendants, dissolved restraining orders, dismissed cases, and in the worst cases, sanctions or reputational damage with the court.

Factor Favours Schedule A Favours another route
Seller profile Many anonymous storefronts selling identical fakes A few identifiable sellers or a known manufacturer
Evidence Completed test buys shipped into the forum Screenshots only, no forum sales
Links between sellers Shared images, listings, payment or logistics data Unrelated sellers with different products
Assets Meaningful balances held in US-facing marketplace accounts Little money left in reachable accounts
Goal Fast takedown plus financial deterrence Supply-chain disruption at source

Building a Schedule A case that survives scrutiny

  • ☐  Confirm your registrations cover the goods being counterfeited — registered marks and, where relevant, design patents and copyrights.
  • ☐  Complete test purchases shipped into the forum for each defendant, and keep chain-of-custody records.
  • ☐  Document real connections between joined defendants — shared product images, identical listings, common logistics or payment patterns — rather than relying on a general swarm theory.
  • ☐  Group defendants conservatively; several tighter cases are often stronger than one sprawling one.
  • ☐  Investigate defendant addresses before seeking electronic service, and record the effort.
  • ☐  Avoid any appearance of judge shopping, including dropping and re-filing defendants after assignment.
  • ☐  Plan for bonds, asset-freeze scope, and appearances by defendants who contest the case.

Pro tip: Treat Schedule A as one tool in a coordinated programme, not the whole programme. Marketplace brand-protection portals, customs recordation, and enforcement at the source in China often deliver more durable results — and the best Schedule A cases are built on intelligence gathered through those other channels.

The cross-border picture

Most Schedule A defendants are offshore sellers, and many source from manufacturers in China. Two other developments affect the same networks. In the US, the end of duty-free de minimis treatment has changed how low-value parcels enter the country, as we explained in De Minimis Is Gone. In China, the revised Trademark Law that takes effect on January 1, 2027 adds penalties for bad-faith filers and recognises online use, as covered in China’s New Trademark Law. Brands that combine US litigation with China registrations and customs recordation tend to see counterfeit volumes fall further and stay down longer.

The bottom line

Schedule A litigation is not going away, and in 2026 it is being used more than ever. What has changed is the margin for error. Courts now expect jurisdictional evidence, genuine links between defendants, diligent service efforts, and clean conduct around case assignment. Brands that meet that standard still have a fast, effective weapon against online counterfeiters; brands that do not are finding their cases severed or dismissed. If you are weighing a Schedule A programme — or wondering why your last one underdelivered — we can help you design an enforcement strategy that fits your marketplaces, your markets, and your budget.

Ready to protect your IP?

Book a free 15-minute strategy call with our team.

Book a Free Strategy Call

Disclaimer: This article provides general information about IP strategy and should not be relied upon as legal advice. IP laws vary significantly by jurisdiction and every business situation is unique. Consult qualified counsel about your specific circumstances.